When I moved to Iceland, I didn't want a plastic puffin. I wanted the things Icelanders actually keep on their shelves: a Royal Copenhagen bowl, a sturdy ceramic mug, a wool sweater someone has worn for years. I've spent more than five years hunting for those things in Reykjavík's secondhand shops, most weeks more than once, and I still rarely come home empty-handed.

This guide covers five places, all open as of November 2026. Three are charity shops, one is a small antique shop run by a group of women, and one is the flea market every other guide mentions. If you're after secondhand clothes rather than objects, I've written a separate guide to Reykjavík's booth shops.

Where the stock comes from

Almost everything at Góði hirðirinn, Hertex and the Red Cross was donated. Góði hirðirinn's stock comes from what locals leave at the city's recycling centres, where the Red Cross also has its own donation spot. Both the Red Cross and Hertex take bags of donations straight to their shops as well.

That's what makes these shops good for souvenirs. You're buying what Icelandic homes actually had in them, not what was made for visitors.

The five shops at a glance

ShopWhereDowntownBest for
Rauði krossinn (Red Cross)Laugavegur 12YesWool sweaters, mittens, hats
KolaportiðOld HarbourYesCollectors' stalls and Icelandic food, weekends only
Góði hirðirinnKöllunarklettsvegur 1, next to BarnaloppanNoEverything: furniture, books, kitchenware
HertexOutside downtownNoOriginal art, ceramics, wool
Portið markaðurAuðbrekka 21, KópavogurNoNordic antiques and vintage Christmas decorations, Thursdays and Saturdays only

Downtown, on foot from your hotel

Rauði krossinn (Red Cross) on Laugavegur

Where Laugavegur 12 · Good for wool

The Red Cross has several shops around Reykjavík, but the one on Laugavegur is the one I send visitors to. It's small, and it leans hard into wool: Icelandic sweaters, mittens and hats, hung next to clothes with a real vintage feel.

If you came to Iceland wanting a lopapeysa and the price of a new one made you wince, start here. Check the label for the wool content, and look at the cuffs and elbows for wear. Our guide to Icelandic wool explains what to look for.

Kolaportið

Where by the Old Harbour · Open weekends

Kolaportið is the one place on this list I rarely visit. It's Reykjavík's indoor weekend market, and these days it's part café and bar, part food hall, where you can buy harðfiskur (dried fish) and other Icelandic specialities.

Among the stalls are a few sellers of antiques, used goods and collectibles: Pokémon cards, old military memorabilia, T-shirts. If you collect something specific, it's worth a wander. For more detail, see our guide to Kolaportið.

Worth the bus ride

Góði hirðirinn

Where Köllunarklettsvegur 1, next to Barnaloppan · Good for everything

This is the one locals love. Góði hirðirinn is a huge hall, and it really does have everything: pianos, sofas, tables and wardrobes, paintings and prints, tools, and shelves of books, mostly Icelandic but with plenty in English.

For a visitor, the small things are the prize. Work through the glasses, cups, pots and pans, candlesticks and decorations, and you'll find pieces that look far better on a shelf back home than anything from a souvenir shop. Around Christmas the decoration shelves fill up.

There's clothing too, including bins where you fill a bag for one price, and a more curated rail priced about the same as the booth shops. Prices across the store vary: plenty is very cheap, and some of it isn't. There's a big car park.

Hertex

Where outside downtown · Good for art, ceramics, wool

Hertex is the shop I almost never leave empty-handed. It's the Salvation Army's charity shop, and a big one, a little way out of downtown, with furniture, homeware, china, decorations, books and magazines, children's things and toys, and a lot of clothing. There's a rack of wool sweaters, and it has never been empty when I've visited.

This week I came home with a signed pastel original by an Icelandic artist for 2,000 kr, plus a basket. Another time it was an easel for about 1,500 kr. It's where I'd go for an Icelandic mug, a piece of ceramics or a framed print.

Portið markaður

Where Auðbrekka 21, Kópavogur · Open Thu 2 to 8 pm, Sat 11 am to 4 pm · Good for Nordic antiques

My favourite. Portið is a small shop in Kópavogur, run by a handful of Icelandic women who each have their own corner. It's the closest thing Iceland has to a proper antique shop for small pieces.

There are only three or four pieces of furniture. The rest is lamps, figurines, design pieces and collectibles, including Royal Copenhagen, plus a few books. Much of it looks Danish and Swedish to me. If you want one souvenir that's actually good, this is where I'd look: a piece of Nordic porcelain or a small design object travels well and won't look like it came from an airport.

The catch is the hours. It's only open on Thursdays, from 2 to 8 pm, and Saturdays, from 11 am to 4 pm, and it posts any changes on its Facebook page. In December it often opens every day, because Icelanders do their Christmas shopping there.

Also worth a look

Two shops from my clothing guide sell objects too. Gullið mitt, outside downtown, has glasses, books and small items alongside its clothes. Barnaloppan, next door to Góði hirðirinn, is full of toys.

Vintage Nordic Christmas decorations

If you're here in November or December, go to Portið. They bring out boxes of vintage Christmas baubles and decorations, many of them Nordic: paper ornaments and wooden candle holders, the kind of thing Danish and Swedish families have hung for decades. Góði hirðirinn's decoration shelves are worth a look at the same time of year.

How to shop like a regular

  • Read the label. Wool, cashmere, alpaca, silk and linen turn up all the time, often for less than synthetic clothes cost new.
  • Turn porcelain over. The factory mark on the base tells you what you're holding.
  • Go back. The stock changes constantly, so a shop that had nothing for you on Monday may have exactly the thing on Thursday.
  • Think about your suitcase. Small and light travels best. Wrap anything fragile in your clothes, and leave the furniture to people who live here.